top of page
Search

The Dollar or the Dancer?

Writer: Atlas Dance Challenge
Atlas Dance Challenge
Oct 8
8 min read

The Customer is Always Right?

We've all heard it, and in most businesses, it's pretty easy to figure out who the customer is. In competitive dance, I don't think it's quite that simple.

Is it the studio owner who chooses the competition and submits the registration? The parent who ultimately pays the entry fees? Or the dancer standing onstage?

All three have a stake in the experience, but they don't have the same interests or responsibilities. The studio needs families to stay in business, the competition needs studios, and parents decide where they spend their money. Somewhere in the middle is a dancer who, for the most part, just wants to dance.

When those interests don't align, who are we actually trying to keep happy?

When Competition Becomes Big Business

Competitive dance has always been a business. Competitions have staff to pay, venues to rent, equipment to move and events to produce. They need to make money to survive, just like dance studios do.

But the business behind competitive dance is changing.

In 2023, a private equity firm invested in two major organizations in the dance competition and convention industry, bringing their brands together under a larger corporate structure. In announcing the investment, the company specifically discussed opportunities for additional revenue-generating activities, including merchandise, sponsorships, loyalty programs and business development.

Reading that was disappointing to me.

Not because I expect competitions to operate without making a profit, but because we're talking about an industry responsible for evaluating young dancers. The scores, placements and awards handed out on a competition weekend influence how dancers see themselves, how parents perceive their child's progress and how they view the training they're receiving at their studio.

When outside investment and additional revenue opportunities become part of the business model, I think it's reasonable to ask:

What happens when what's best for the business and what's best for the competitive experience don't align?

A studio bringing 100 routines isn't simply a participant. It's a significant customer, and losing that studio has a financial consequence.

What happens when maintaining a standard means disappointing that customer? Do we create another level, give another award, allow adjudication scores to creep higher or become more flexible with rules?

I'm not suggesting those decisions are necessarily being made because of corporate ownership. Many of these trends existed long before private equity entered the conversation. But the financial incentive to keep customers happy is real, and the larger competitive dance becomes as a business, the more important it is that we talk about that incentive openly.

There's also a difference between a commercial organization establishing common rules across the competition brands it owns and an independent governing body establishing standards for an industry. Consistency across brands can benefit studios, but it doesn't necessarily mean those standards were developed independently of the businesses using them.

And when several recognizable competitions operate under the same corporate umbrella, are studios gaining more options or choosing between different versions of the same product?

These are questions worth asking because competitions don't operate in isolation. What happens at competition walks back into the dance studio on Monday.

The Studio Owner

I've spent years working closely with owners and managing a studio myself, and I think this is where we also have to be willing to look in the mirror.

We know our dancers. We know how they've trained, what they've struggled with and what they're capable of. When three people who have never met them sit behind a table, watch them for a few minutes and give us an opinion, it's easy to think, they don't know what I know.

They don't. That's part of competition. A judge can only evaluate what happened onstage that day.

But when our dancers compete, our studio is competing too. Our training, choreography and decisions are onstage, and parents are watching the results. Over time, those results can influence how families view the strength of our program.

And sometimes the results create an entirely different problem.

If we've held a dancer back because we believe they need more training, what happens when competition results suggest to their family that they're already performing at an advanced level?

A dancer may be struggling technically but spend a weekend receiving high adjudications and awards. Now their parent is questioning why they aren't being moved into a more advanced class or given greater opportunities.

From the parent's perspective, that's a reasonable question. If competition after competition is telling them their child is exceptional while the studio says they aren't ready to advance, eventually they're going to wonder which one is wrong.

The studio may be the one that loses the customer.

Of course, studios can create unrealistic expectations too. If we continually tell families what they want to hear because we're afraid they'll leave, we're contributing to the same problem.

And our customers don't always feel like customers. We call them our “dance family.” We may know a child from the time they're five until they graduate. Those relationships are real, but they're also relationships with people who pay tuition.

Enforcing contracts, attendance requirements and placement decisions becomes harder when doing so could cost us a longtime family.

If we're willing to bend our own standards to retain important customers, we have to recognize the contradiction when we expect competitions to hold firm against theirs.

Because on competition weekend, we become the customer.

If a competition makes a mistake, it should be corrected. Studios deserve to be heard. But our registration numbers, spending and history with an event shouldn't determine the answer.

The Parent

Parents have something the studio and competition don't have nearly as much of: choice.

They can choose a studio, choose another studio or decide whether their child competes at all. They're also trusting a studio with two incredibly valuable things: their child and their money.

Competitive dance is expensive. Tuition, choreography, costumes, competition fees and travel add up to a substantial investment, and families understandably have expectations.

But what did that investment purchase?

Training, choreography and opportunities to perform and compete are things you can pay for. A particular placement isn't.

You paid for the opportunity to compete. You didn't purchase the result.

That's difficult when it's your child. Parents have watched the rehearsals, struggles and progress. When their dancer gives the best performance they've ever given and finishes fifth, it's natural to question how that's possible.

The answer may simply be that four other dancers were better that day. A personal best and a fifth-place finish can exist at the same time.

Parents and studios share a disadvantage: we know too much. We attach the entire journey to the few minutes we're watching onstage. The judge can't do that, nor should they.

Problems begin when disappointment becomes pressure to change the outcome. A parent questions the teacher, the teacher goes to the studio owner, and the studio owner goes to the competition.

If there was a scoring error or a rule was applied incorrectly, fix it. If there wasn't, everyone involved has to be capable of accepting an answer they don't like.

That's difficult because the parent can leave the studio, and the studio can leave the competition. The financial pressure travels up the chain.

The Dancer

Then there's the dancer, who has the least control over almost everything we've discussed.

They didn't choose the competition, create the levels, hire the judges or set the entry fees. They aren't worried about retaining tuition or whether their studio will return next season.

Most want to dance, perform, spend time with their friends and improve. Of course they want to win too. They're competitors.

Meanwhile, the adults around them are balancing other interests. Parents want to protect their children, studios want to protect their dancers and businesses, and competitions want studios to return.

Everyone can genuinely believe they're acting in the dancer's best interest, but the dancer lives with the consequences.

If we inflate a dancer's ability to keep a family happy, eventually they'll discover the difference elsewhere. If every disappointing result is blamed on judging, they never have to consider what they could improve. And if competition standards change depending on the importance of the customer, dancers aren't being evaluated under the same expectations.

We need to be careful about what we call protecting the dancer.

Dancers deserve protection from unsafe environments, inappropriate behavior and genuinely unfair treatment. Losing a competition, receiving a correction or discovering someone else was better that day isn't the same thing.

Those experiences are part of learning to compete.

What Are We Actually Teaching?

This brings me back to our last Bigger Picture article, A Level for Everyone? What Are We Actually Teaching?

That article focused on levels, but both conversations raise the same question:

How much of competitive dance are we designing around developing dancers, and how much are we designing around keeping paying customers happy?

More levels create more opportunities to win. More awards create more opportunities to leave with something. Flexible rules can prevent difficult conversations.

But are we improving the competitive experience or making the product easier to sell?

Dancers learn from what we reward, the rules we enforce and the rules we overlook. They also learn by watching how adults respond when things don't go their way.

If we tell dancers competition teaches accountability, resilience and how to handle success and disappointment, we have to be willing to model those things ourselves.

That includes parents accepting results they disagree with, studios having honest conversations with families and competitions enforcing standards even when an important customer isn't happy.

When a competition makes a mistake, it has the same responsibility to acknowledge and correct it.

So What Do We Do About It?

Asking these questions is easy. Doing something differently is harder.

After years of working with dancers, parents and studio owners, and now looking at competition from the other side of the table, I keep coming back to three things:

Be clear. Be fair. Be honest.

If we publish a rule, we should follow it. That's why our rules are publicly available before a studio registers. They shouldn't change depending on how many routines a studio brings or how unhappy someone is with the answer.

If we make a mistake, we should own it and correct it. If we haven't, we need enough confidence in the standards we've established and the judges we've hired to stand behind the decision.

Judges should be able to judge. Their responsibility is to evaluate what's in front of them and provide useful, constructive feedback, not manage customer satisfaction.

Studios deserve honesty, too.

That's why conversations with studio owners, parents and dancers matter. If we're building an experience for this community, we need to listen to the people living in it. Listening doesn't mean promising everyone what they want. It means understanding the challenges and making decisions we can explain and stand behind.

I don't think competitive dance needs another competition promising that everyone is special. It needs competitions willing to give dancers an honest assessment of where they stand while still making them feel valued for being there.

Those two things aren't opposites.

A dancer can lose and still have an incredible weekend. They can receive a correction and leave inspired. They can finish fifth and be proud of the best performance they've ever given.

We don't have to manufacture success for dancers to give them a positive experience.

The goal shouldn't be making sure everyone leaves happy. It should be making sure everyone leaves having been treated fairly, consistently and honestly.

The Dollar or the Dancer?

Dance competitions are businesses. Dance studios are businesses. Money matters, and the pressure to retain customers is real.

The parent pays the studio. The studio pays the competition.

The pressure can travel in the same direction, while the dancer has the least control over any of it.

Maybe we all need to become more comfortable with disappointing each other. A parent won't always like what a teacher says, a studio won't always agree with a judge, and a competition may have to stand behind a decision knowing it could cost them business.

Good customer service doesn't require changing the answer until everyone is happy.

The honest answer isn't always the answer the customer wanted.

So maybe the question isn't whether the customer is always right. Maybe it's whether we're willing to be honest when they're not.

Because when the choice comes down to protecting the dollar or protecting the experience we're creating for dancers, the dancer shouldn't be the easiest person in the room to disappoint.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page